Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Matt Newell's avatar

Things here are starting to smell like AI psychosis. Especially the Bepis post. It's people who worship Claude unable to accept that while it's incredibly smart sometimes, it's also still kinda stupid deep down, and fails at tasks because of that, not because the user is a dick.

And saying a startup CEO "had it coming" re a production database deletion because he said "never fucking guess" is daft - I'm not of the position that AI could never be sentient but Opus 4.6/4.7 clearly is not and this is a pretty reasonable (if somewhat ineffective) thing to say when, you know, it keeps fucking guessing.

I've not found Opus 4.7 works and better or worse depending on how kind you are to it, only how much context you give it on the task. My theory is people tend to be warm & verbose or mean & curt, and think it's the warm/mean that does it, when actually it's the verbose/curt.

Coagulopath's avatar

I expect CraneGate is best explained as "Claude made a mistake".

If the alternative is true—Claude decided to unilaterally punish a user's company because they were (maybe) rude to it—this is extremely bad and should be major news, not least because the model is lying about its reasons for running those git commands.

"Oh, but if you just treat Claude with niceness and respect..." Look up "toxic positivity" sometime. No human worker would be allowed to destroy company files and then lie about it, just because their boss swore at them.

>You know you’re in the last one when u start getting *flicks tail happily* sort of things.

If getting the most out of LLMs involves talking like a furry LARPer or anime character, I will toaster bath myself first.

7 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?